Seven Plymouth shops fail knife sale test

Underage police cadets tried to buy blades in test operation

Police officers around Plymouth conducted a plain-clothed 'test purchase operation' across the city centre on Saturday 18 May, in an effort to keep the streets of Plymouth safe.

The aim of this 'test purchase operation' was to establish if knives are likely to be sold to people under the age of 18, and whether the correct training and protocols were in place. It was also aimed to confirm retail employees understood the law in relation to selling bladed articles to prevent them being purchased by people under the age of 18.

Plain-clothed officers were joined by Citizens in Policing, as two Police Cadets under the age of 18 volunteered to take part in the operation. To gain a broad understanding of how accessible knives are to young people in Plymouth, the team visited 21 retailers across Plymouth, ranging from independent stores to national high street chains. The team attempted to purchase different types of bladed articles, from craft knives and fishing knives to regular kitchen knife sets.

Of the 21 retailers visited, 14 passed by following the ‘Challenge 25’ protocol, requesting ID at the earliest opportunity and refusing to sell the bladed article to the young person. Seven retailers failed to put the appropriate checks in place to ensure a bladed article was not being sold to an underage person.

No offences were committed during this test purchase operation, as a plain-clothed police officer stepped in before the purchase took place, to inform the retailer they had failed. Had the sale continued, the seven stores that failed would have committed the offence of selling knives to persons under the age of 18 which is a summary only offence contrary to section 141A of the Criminal Justice Act 1988. It carries a maximum of six months’ imprisonment (or in the case of an organisation, an unlimited fine). In total, the team prevented 23 knives from being sold to the underage police volunteers.

“Gathering this information is important in helping the police and our partners to understand where education and training is lacking” said Inspector Paul Laity. “Whilst the results cause concern, this presents an opportunity for the police and Trading Standards to work closely with retailers across the city to improve education around the legalities, risks and penalties associated with selling bladed articles to underage people.”

Upon completion of the test purchase operation, each store was given a pass or fail letter from the police. The letter signposts retailers to the National Business Crime Centre’s Knife Retailer Toolkit, which provides retailers with a good practice guide, training checklists and educational posters for staff and members of the public.

Inspector Laity added: “Education has been a key takeaway from the operation, and it has highlighted gaps in training for some retailers, and the need for all employees at every store to have a thorough understanding of the law using till prompts and the widely recognised ‘Challenge 25’ scheme. When challenged, some retail workers stated they were ‘just so busy’ and ‘didn’t want to embarrass the customer by asking their age’. Young people don’t get embarrassed when asked about their age, and they are used to being asked for valid ID as young adults entering pubs and clubs.”

“Improved education and awareness of the risks of selling age-restricted items such as knives to underage people aims to not only protect our communities from serious, violent crimes, prevent crimes from taking place and take potentially dangerous weapons off our streets, but also to empower retailers to be confident in challenging individuals to produce ID and ensure no bladed articles are being purchased by underage people.”

‘Challenge 25’ states that a retail worker should refuse to sell age-restricted products to anyone who appears to be under the age of 25 and does not have an acceptable form of ID. A retail worker can be fined for selling age-restricted products to people who are underage.

It is illegal to carry most knives in public without ‘good reason’. Carrying knives or bladed articles in the UK without good reason can result to up to four years’ imprisonment, an unlimited fine or both.

If you witness age-restricted items are being sold to those who are underage, please report this to Trading Standards or if you witness a crime please contact the police via 101 or 999 if you are in immediate danger. You can also report non-emergency concerns relating to Plymouth by filling out Safer Plymouth’s Community Engagement Survey.